The Goldilocks Principal of Startup Capital Raising and Valuation
Your valuation should not be too hot (high), nor too cold (too low), not too hard nor too soft, but just right like Goldilocks's preferred bowl of porridge. That's a quarter in the 2026 pun jar for me ๐
Seriously, as a pre-seed investor I see a fair volume of cap raises and nailing the right range for a valuation sets the tone for success and timeframe for the round.
Pre-seed, what's in a name?
Here's where the "but pre-seed is this not that and seed is this and not that" conversation starts. Let's not get bogged down; let's define pre-seed as the startup's first round or second round. The startup's stage spans "pre-revenue + vision = potential" to "modest revenue + retention = traction".
Are you raising on vision or traction?
When you're pre-revenue, you're raising based on your vision and underlying components like team, moat, unique perspective, unfair advantage, customer intention like LOIs, investor FOMO, etc. These also come into play if you are generating revenue and raising but they're the only factors to price when you're pre-revenue. When you have revenue, the quality of the pipeline. Conversion, retention, CAC, LTV, etc. all paint the picture of the traction you leverage to justify the valuation and round. I often say "the answer to all founder questions about investment is the investor question 'What's your traction?'".
How do investors "calculate" early-stage startup valuations
A startup's value is ultimately set by the market. The pre-seed market is composed of angel investors, angel syndicates and a few VCs like Antler that play at this very high risk end of the market. The investor must decide if they're backing vision or traction or a combination and the best approach. Investors invariably will look at comparable companies at your stage and the investment multiple typical for the business model and industry segment you're in.
There are benchmarks based on business models for early stage startups. These use a multiple of ARR as indicative of valuation. E-commerce businesses for example are valued from 3xโ6x depending on age and size of business. A high growth SaaS business might command a 7xโ10x multiple. You can use 10x ARR as a typical highwater mark when thinking about your startup's valuation. In some "strategic" cases the multiple can exceed 10x.
Clearly pre-revenue startups getting valued based on vision are a bit in limbo โ they can't use a multiple of revenue. They typically get valued in AU between $2Mโ$4M based on the quality of the vision. This is a rule of thumb.
Two valuation case studies for 2025
Case in point, two 2025 pre-seed SaaS raises spring to mind. One Co was pre-revenue with a POC and determined to raise +$1M on a $9M val. Two Co was at $900K ARR and determined to raise +$1M on a $9M val.
One Co was pricing in their forecasted revenues at year one. That's a pretty common mistake and frankly a rookie error. The forecast is helpful as a guide to where the business is heading but an investor is going to discount that to near zero at the POC stage unless there are really firm LOIs to strengthen the case.
One Co got an early "false positive" signal from a Family Office (FO) but struggled to find a lead investor and fill out the round. The FO agreed that the founder-set val of $9M was reasonable. Feedback from VCs was that they were priced too high. I would have valued the round at $2โ$4M based on founder, minimal traction (POC) and suggested a more modest raise amount to preserve equity and drive towards more traction to justify a second pre-seed round at higher valuation. They didn't heed my advice and only time will tell how it all turns out. We'll unpack some of the potential ramifications below.
Two Co was priced right for the market and had interest from top tier pre-seed VCs and strategic angel investors. They could negotiate favorable terms and have quality investors on the cap table to draw upon for their next round. To be sure there's to and fro about a slightly higher valuation but in the end the founder judged they had landed on the right valuation based on market conditions.
So what about One Co, where does it go from here? I predict that the company's next round is going to be priced based on traction ARR + retention + sales funnel. Doing the math, they would raise flat at $1M rev on $9M val. It would be better if they raise when they're at ~$1.8M ARR which would dictate an $18M val. A reasonable conclusion is that they've gotten a great first valuation but they've put themselves under a great deal of pressure to get to ramp revenue and cash to flow positive in order to survive and grow into their valuation. They risk a down round which is often the death knell for an early stage startup, at least one with unicorn ambitions (private company valued at $1B or more). In any event they've set themselves up for some high expectations and heavy pressure from investors and they haven't really hit product market fit (PMF) yet.
If we apply this same thinking and math to Two Co, their $9M val is justified and they're well on their way to +2x valuation for the next raise.
Pricing and selling equity in your tech startup is just another sale but comes with high impact consequences if you don't attract the right investors and set a reasonable valuation based on the market and where you're heading. The pre-seed round(s) setup the company for cap raising success or failure so the whole exercise isn't to be taken lightly and shouldn't be delegated to an agent or representative.
The top reason startups fail is that there isn't a market need for their solution โ i.e. the problem they were trying to solve didn't have enough impact (size, urgency, painfulness). The second reason is they run out of cash which is probably due to a lack of revenue or poor unit economics and an inability to raise capital from investors. So get it right. Read the Feld & Mendelson book Venture Deals, read my other blogs on this topic, talk to founders that have raised and those that haven't. If you have unicorn ambition, become a student of the cap raising game and then play like an elite athlete.
